• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

SEENIT

TV, Film, Broadband, Pay-TV, Games, Computing and Tech | News, Comment & Reviews

  • NEWS
  • FEATURES
  • ADVERTISE
  • Twitter

Broadcasters should consider the desirability of ‘nasty’ judges

February 22, 2010 - Martin Hoscik@seenituk

Not being a huge fan of celebrity ‘talent’ shows I won’t pretend to have seen the comments Dancing on Ice judge Jason Gardiner made about Sharron Davies which prompted 400 complaints but OFCOM kindly repeats them in its adjudication:

“It was like watching faecal matter that won’t flush – it goes around and around and around and in the end it doesn’t go anywhere.”

Apparently there’s nothing to in the broadcasting code to stop people being compared with a turd, especially if the person making the comments has an established record as an “ acerbic ‘nasty’ judge”.

But why do the producers and broadcasters of such shows find the need to include a “nasty” judge in the first place?

Every talent show seems to have them, ever since ‘nasty’ Nigel Lythgoe gave genuine, honest feedback on Pop Idol every show has seemingly felt a desperate need to include someone with a nice line in harsh (and often heavily scripted) put downs.

Surely each judge on the show should be commenting with an open mind, giving praise where deserved, and useful but critical comments where they’re warranted?

The act of casting someone in the role of “nasty” judge means that at least one member of the judging panel is instead approaching their scoring and comments from a position of making a splash and enhancing their reputation.

Why on earth do broadcasters think the licensed humiliation of people seeking to do no more than entertain their rapidly declining audiences does anything good for their image? One can make too much of individual cases but the trend of celebrating the bullying tendencies of a few egocentrics is starting to get worrying.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)

Related

Blu-ray and Gaming Top Buys

David Attenborough’s A Perfect Planet is getting a 4K Blu-ray release

Doctor Who: Sylvester McCoy and Bonnie Langford reunite in trailer for Season 24 Blu-ray release

Batman: Soul Of The Dragon comes to DVD and Blu-ray next month

RECENT

BT Sport to show 26 Premier League games this month

Godzilla vs. Kong: Watch the brand-new trailer

Robert Kirkman’s Invincible is coming to Amazon Prime Video

Watch Danielle Macdonald, Hugh Skinner and Joanna Lumley in Falling for Figaro trailer

Popular

Sky bags first run rights to Entertainment One catalogue

Freesat adds BBC Sounds to app line-up

Coming To America sequel to get global release on Amazon Prime Video

Hitman developers announce new James Bond game

Featured

Ofcom calls for greater social and geographic diversity in TV and radio

BT Sport app now available on Now TV devices

StarzPlay is now available from Rakuten TV

Britbox – What does the new UK-centric streaming service offer?

Popular Topics

  • Amazon Prime Video
  • BritBox
  • Freeview Play
  • Set Top Box Reviews

ADVERTISE ON SEENIT

We’re pleased to offer a number of advertising opportunities to high quality brands including sponsored content, competitions and advertising placements.

Please contact us for details.

MORE FROM US

Copyright © 2021 · All Rights Reserved · Contact Us · Copyright · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy
MayorWatch Publications Limited · 20-22 Wenlock Road · London N1 7GU · Company Number 6291816