• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

SEENIT

TV, Film, Broadband, Pay-TV, Games, Computing and Tech | News, Comment & Reviews

  • NEWS
  • FEATURES
  • ADVERTISE
  • Twitter

Is the iPad really unsuitable as an ereader?

May 31, 2011 - Martin Hoscik@seenituk

Too heavy? The iPad weights less than a book. Photo: Apple.
I’m a pluralist kind of a guy, on the whole I think it’s best to leave others to buy and use whatever kit they want for the job at hand.

The only times I go out of my way to intervene is if a friend of relative is thinking about buying something I’ve had a bad experience with or know that someone else has.

Not everyone is so hands-off.

A few days ago a very tech-passionate acquaintance launched into a lecture on why I was wrong to use my iPad as an eBook reader.

This admonishment largely consisted of a list of supposed failings which you’ll find repeated all over the web:

  1. The iPad is too heavy/big for use an ereader
  2. ‘Poor’ text quality means an backlighting means LCD displays aren’t suitable for ‘long-form reading’
  3. LCD displays are reflective and suffer from screen glare
  4. The iPad is too fragile to just ‘chuck in a bag’ like one would a book

There may have been others but let’s look at these most popular objections in turn:

The iPad’s too heavy for use an ereader
I’m currently reading Jeffery Deaver’s superb 007 reboot Carte Blanche which is available in physical form as a hardback. I confess I’ve not taken my kitchen scales into the local Waterstone’s to double-check but I suspect the paper version of the book weighs in at a lot more than my iPad 2’s 1.35 pounds.

It’s also bulkier and less likely to be in my bag or rucksack whenever I have an expected chance to read a few more pages.

A clear win for the iPad!

Poor’ text quality means an backlighting means LCD displays aren’t suitable for ‘long-form reading’
Says who?

This is one of those highly subjective claims which get repeated as unassailable, inarguable fact when they’re nothing of the sort.

Like most people working in 2011, I spend much of my day looking at a backlit LCD computer screen and have no problem doing so. How is reading a lengthy document on a laptop screen any different from reading a book on my iPad?

As for the supposedly ‘poor’ text quality – my iPad let’s me pick the font and text size I find most comfortable for my particular needs.

Of course, some people may have sight or eye issues which make a backlit screen less suitable for them but the ‘one size fits all’ nature of the assertion is simply absurd.

LCD displays are reflective and suffer from screen glare
Living in London means there’s always plenty of shade so this is rarely an issue for me. Yes, on occasion bright overhead lights on a train have meant the screen is more reflective than normal but I’ve generally found that adjusting the backlight level solves it.

Again, I appreciate some people may find a reflection or bright spot troublesome but it’s a matter of personal preference/tolerance.

It may be a reason for SOME PEOPLE not to read on an iPad but it’s not a reason for NO-ONE to do so.

The iPad is too fragile to just ‘chuck in a bag’ like one would a book
This one always bemuses me. It seems to be a subconscious repetition of the message presented in Amazon’s advert that your dog can lick your Kindle screen and you can place keys on it with no ill effect.

I paid something like £600 for my iPad, when I carry it in a bag it sits inside a memory foam case to protect it against the crowds of rush hour train users who might cram against it. It takes about 10 seconds to put it in the case and do up my bag.

I don’t see this as a big deal.

And besides, as posts about cracked and frozen Kindles in Amazon’s own forums show, it’s generally a good idea to treat ANY electronic device with some care.

Why does it matter what we use?
I’ve never really understood why it matters to anyone what other people buy and use.

Personally I wouldn’t want a Kindle, I have no use for something I have to carry in addition to the kit already in my bag but, while I have doubts about the longevity of grey screen devices in an increasingly mainstream marketplace, I don’t feel any need to lecture people I meet on why they’ve made a ‘wrong’ purchasing decision.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)

Related

Tagged With: ebooks

Blu-ray and Gaming Top Buys

David Attenborough’s A Perfect Planet is getting a 4K Blu-ray release

Doctor Who: Sylvester McCoy and Bonnie Langford reunite in trailer for Season 24 Blu-ray release

Batman: Soul Of The Dragon comes to DVD and Blu-ray next month

RECENT

BT Sport to show 26 Premier League games this month

Godzilla vs. Kong: Watch the brand-new trailer

Robert Kirkman’s Invincible is coming to Amazon Prime Video

Watch Danielle Macdonald, Hugh Skinner and Joanna Lumley in Falling for Figaro trailer

Popular

Sky bags first run rights to Entertainment One catalogue

Freesat adds BBC Sounds to app line-up

Coming To America sequel to get global release on Amazon Prime Video

Hitman developers announce new James Bond game

Featured

Ofcom calls for greater social and geographic diversity in TV and radio

BT Sport app now available on Now TV devices

StarzPlay is now available from Rakuten TV

Britbox – What does the new UK-centric streaming service offer?

Popular Topics

  • Amazon Prime Video
  • BritBox
  • Freeview Play
  • Set Top Box Reviews

ADVERTISE ON SEENIT

We’re pleased to offer a number of advertising opportunities to high quality brands including sponsored content, competitions and advertising placements.

Please contact us for details.

MORE FROM US

Copyright © 2021 · All Rights Reserved · Contact Us · Copyright · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy
MayorWatch Publications Limited · 20-22 Wenlock Road · London N1 7GU · Company Number 6291816