• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

SEENIT

TV, Film, Broadband, Pay-TV, Games, Computing and Tech | News, Comment & Reviews

  • NEWS
  • FEATURES
  • ADVERTISE
  • Twitter

This version of Top Gear is dead – BBC bosses must take time to radically rework the show

March 25, 2015 - Martin Hoscik@seenituk

Image: BBC Worldwide Ltd/Ellis O'Brien
Image: BBC Worldwide Ltd/Ellis O’Brien
Like millions of fans around the world, I’m disappointed that Jeremy Clarkson will no longer be part of Top Gear, that the BBC have sacked him and that he made it necessary for them to do so.

On the basis of Ken MacQuarrie’s findings, it’s clear Clarkson’s behaviour went far beyond that reported in recent weeks and that BBC bosses had no realistic alternative but to drop him from the show.

I don’t believe in simple, black and white opinions so I’m not in the least contorted or troubled by simultaneously condemning Clarkson’s actions while also being disappointed that he’ll no longer be part of Top Gear.

But I’m clear that the person responsible isn’t Oisin Tymon or Tony Hall, but Clarkson himself.

Sadly not all of the show’s fans seem able to comprehend this and have spent the hours since Clarkson’s sacking filling social media with threatening comments towards Tymon and Hall.

At the other end of the spectrum are Clarkson’s most devoted detractors, many of whom are wetting themselves in glee at his departure.

The first group are reprehensible. The second seem unaware that axing Clarkson, necessary as it was, places at risk tens of millions of pounds raised from the sale of the show and tie-in merchandise which is then fed into the BBC’s wider programming budget.

Not only does Top Gear cover its own production costs, it covers the entire annual cost of BBC Four or those of a couple of high-end drama series.

Unless the BBC can hit on a winning formula for the show’s post-Clarkson years the decision some are celebrating today could easily see the axing of one or more shows that they enjoy.

None of which, because it seems this can’t be said enough times, makes it OK for Clarkson to have hit one of his team.

But it does mean the BBC, which is under huge pressure to raise as much money as possible from commercial activities, has some hard decisions ahead.

The worst thing it could do is re-hire Clarkson’s co-stars Richard Hammond and James May and ask them to carry on the banter with a new third host.

Their era of the show needs to end with their colleague’s departure if Top Gear is to have any chance of a future and Licence Fee payers are to be spared the loss of a vital cash cow.


Top Gear went off the air in 2001 and came back a year later with a radically different format and this is what needs to happen now.

The very earliest the BBC should considering airing the show is Christmas 2016 when audiences are bored of the usual festive fare and may consider giving it a go.

And they should spend the time between now and then working on a wholly new format for a line-up of presenters who aren’t being asked to present someone else’s show.

Everything associated with the Clarkson era – stars in reasonably priced cars, Gambon corner and even the Stig – needs to be consigned to the bin.

In fact the BBC should probably allow the masked racer to join his colleagues in whatever new endeavour they pursue because as long as he remains on screen he’ll serve as a constant reminder of what used to be and its ignominious death.

Those of us who like Clarkson, Hammond and May’s routine may not like whatever replaces them but chances are the trio will be popping up on a rival network, Netflix, Amazon Prime or DVD pretty soon.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)

Related

Blu-ray and Gaming Top Buys

Batman: Soul Of The Dragon comes to DVD and Blu-ray next month

Classic Doctor Who story The Web of Fear is coming to Blu-ray

Francis Ford Coppola’s re-edit of The Godfather: Part III gets official trailer

RECENT

Sky and Studiocanal announce new movie deal

Jeremy Brett’s definitive Sherlock Holmes arrives on BritBox this week

Dawn French and Richard Curtis reunite for Vicar of Dibley documentary

EE brings 5G to 13 new towns and cities

Popular

Sky bags first run rights to Entertainment One catalogue

Freesat adds BBC Sounds to app line-up

Coming To America sequel to get global release on Amazon Prime Video

Hitman developers announce new James Bond game

Featured

Ofcom calls for greater social and geographic diversity in TV and radio

BT Sport app now available on Now TV devices

StarzPlay is now available from Rakuten TV

Britbox – What does the new UK-centric streaming service offer?

Popular Topics

  • Amazon Prime Video
  • BritBox
  • Freeview Play
  • Set Top Box Reviews

ADVERTISE ON SEENIT

We’re pleased to offer a number of advertising opportunities to high quality brands including sponsored content, competitions and advertising placements.

Please contact us for details.

MORE FROM US

Copyright © 2021 · All Rights Reserved · Contact Us · Copyright · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy
MayorWatch Publications Limited · 20-22 Wenlock Road · London N1 7GU · Company Number 6291816